Platelet-Rich Plasma Therapy: Much Ado about Nothing?

March 18th, 2011 | Sources: Commentary

Subjects:

Platelet-rich plasma (PRP) therapy became a hot topic among professional and recreational athletes after some studies suggested it could hasten wound healing and several high-profile athletes reported using it as they rehabbed from various injuries.  But recently, the news hasn’t been quite so good. For those not in the know, let’s do a quick review of the subject.

Runningshoes 300x254 Platelet Rich Plasma Therapy: Much Ado about Nothing?PRP therapy involves extracting and centrifuging a person’s blood to create a concentrated broth of growth factors and white cells, and then then injecting the stew directly into injured tissue. The growth factors supposedly promote healing.

PRP therapy has been used for numerous conditions including tennis elbow and pulls, sprains and strains of dozens of different muscles, tendons and whatnot.

The treatment became buzzworthy after animal studies showed that it fostered collagen and new blood vessel formation in the tendons of animals that had been surgically injured by scientists.

The buzz grew after reports surfaced that Tiger Woods used PRP therapy to treat a sore knee, NFL player Chris Canty used it for a hamstring injury, and itinerant MLB pitcher Cliff Lee used it for an abdominal strain. After these high-profile athletes claimed to be satisfied with the results, recreational athletes began demanding PRP therapy for themselves, even though it cost $1,000 per shot and isn’t covered by most insurance plans.

Alas, recent scientific studies of PRP therapy should dampen that enthusiasm, at least a bit. It just doesn’t seem to work in humans with overuse injuries and strains, according to these studies.

This month for example, S. de Jonge and colleagues at Erasmus University (Rotterdam) published one-year follow-up data on their placebo-controlled trial of PRP therapy for Achilles tendinopathy. Their original report showed no benefits at 6 months, and the extended follow-up showed the same thing (no benefit). de Jonge’s group concluded there is “no evidence for the use of platelet-rich plasma” therapy in this particular condition.

A second paper by Leon Creaney and colleagues, which is in the publication queue at the British Journal of Sports Medicine, reportedly found that PRP therapy was not more effective (indeed, it was quite possibly less effective) than injections of un-centrifuged blood for the treatment of tennis elbow.

How do we reconcile the outcomes of the favorable animal studies with those from the human trials, which were negative? One theory is that the animal studies involved acute injuries, which provoke a vigorous inflammatory response that may well be enhanced by PRP therapy. By contrast, overuse injuries, strains, sprains and pulled muscles provoke a less robust response. PRP therapy seems unable to enhance the healing process in such instances. Of course, it may also be the case that animals just respond differently to PRP therapy than humans.

In any case, it’s clear that scientists don’t yet understand the mechanisms by which PRP therapy works, if and when it does. This uncertainty has prompted the International Olympic Committee to issue the following note of caution regarding PRP therapy: “We believe more work on the basic science needs to be undertaken,” and until such work is complete, athletes should “proceed with caution in the use of” PRP therapy for the treatment of sports-related injuries.

Your doctor or trainer knows best, but perhaps good old-fashioned physical therapy and RICE (rest, ice, compression, elevation) is the best way to go.


 

Comments

  1. DJ | 20/04/11

    What does the research say about using PRP for post-surgical procedures such as arthroscopic surgery or achilles tendosis surgery?

  2. Scott | 27/07/11

    This is a crock of you know what! People are so quick to jump around and say something doesn’t work just because one study for one type of injury shows something. I say something because what are the percentages of this double blind placebo study that was done. If 51% said there was no improvement and 49% said there was then BANG it must not work…right? Here is my experence, tear of the patella tendon (a lengthwise tear that could not be surgically repaired). Two PRP injections and a month later the tear is gone! My knee feels great and I am back to strength training. A second example, a hopeful Olympic triple jumper tears his patella tendon nearly off when a box he is doing squats to breaks. After a number of injections of PRR his tendon is healed and he is currently jumping almost 16m. I saw the ultrasound before and after and all I can say is WOW! No drugs, no cutting, no stitches and a tendon with very little blood flow is fixed! But PRP doesn’t work, I wish people would do a little more research before publishing things online because it makes them less of a reliable source for information.

  3. Kyle | 7/12/11

    I can’t see how it would not work but are there any health risks?

  4. Roodabeh | 22/01/12

    HI DEAR DR. i am from Iran . And i am medical doctor (GP)Ihave 2 questions: i want to do PRP for khnee for my father.how many kit of PRP we need for every khnee?it is better to use 1 kit for every khnee or on kit for boath of khnees (boath of them use here by orthopethic dr).and I want to khnow abouth the injection.we inject PRP in the jiont the same az cotrtcosterid injecthino? or it is diffrent? thanks for yor attention

  5. Jim | 24/02/12

    What are the health implications? That would be my only concern…

    Otherwise nice read!

  6. Joe | 2/06/12

    I was told the I needed a total knee replacement in April 2012 as I could hardly walk upstairs at my home without tremendous pain, so I took a chance at PRP on April 27, after 2 treatments and a little over a month I can now walk upstairs or downstairs pain free, I’m amazed. And I recently cancelled my TKA surgery that I had scheduled in August.

Add Your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

We just want the site to look nice!
  • Comment Policy


    Pizaazz encourages the posting of comments that are pertinent to issues raised in our posts. The appearance of a comment on Pizaazz does not imply that we agree with or endorse it.

    We do not accept comments containing profanity, spam, unapproved advertising, or unreasonably hateful statements.



























Contact us if interested